I can't think of a more-hyped and
less-productive goodie than the 56k modem. The struggle
between x2 and K56flex standards, the failure for 56.6
downloads to actually travel at 56kbps, the inability
for these modems to deal with even the slightest phone
line imperfections, the fact that many uploads still
crawl along at 14.4 kbps, all have contributed to making
56k modems a lot of overhyped hot air. Nevertheless,
millions of users have bought 'em. Look for newer
technologies like cable modem, DSL/ADSL, ISDN and its
new sibling AO/DI, T1, and satellite transmission to
render analog modem technology obsolete, but it won't
happen today. The good news is that the two incompatible
standards have given way to a third standard which
operates both x2 and K56flex. Known as V.90, this third
standard has finally come into place.
An upgrade for the x2 is available from
www.3com.com/56k, but K56flex owners might gnash
their teeth when they find out how difficult a time they
may have in upgrading their hardware. If their ISPs
don't upgrade to match their souped-up K56 modems,
download speeds will actually drop to the old 28.8
standard. Worse, there doesn't seem to be a "one size
fits all" upgrade for K56 modems - upgrades differ
between manufacturers (check the Web sites). And worst
of all, some of the early K56es have their code built
into ROM, which means swapping out ROM chips. Why?
Rockwell only built 1MB of memory into their hardware,
whereas the x2s have 2MB, plenty for the new V.90 code,
which is available for any x2 modem from
www.3com.com/56k, the U.S. Robotics site. If you're
in the market for a new modem, the V.90s currently for
sale are field-upgradable, so whatever last-minute
tweaks come down the pike can be implemented in your
modem by simply downloading a patch. (Warning: None of
the V.90 modems tested in a recent Windows Magazine
runthrough functioned as they should have. Second
warning: many flash upgrades aren't reversible, so make
sure you know what you're doing before you do it.) Maybe
you should start saving your pennies after all.
The V.90 standards have been approved
and should be ratified by the time you read this; check
up on the latest at www.v90.com/. Rather try
ISDN? Read up on the technology at www.isdnzone.com/dyndefault.htm.
If you do purchase a V.90 modem, remember these tidbits:
It's rare at best for any modem connection to move
anywhere near as fast as rated. If your 56k connection
moves at, say, the mid 30s, you're doing well. Don't
hope for speed miracles just yet. Secondly, not all ISPs
support V.90, or even the same V.90 standards. AOL and
most other national ISPs have either completely changed
over or are in the process; others, particularly some
local or regional providers, haven't been as quick on
the uptake. Ask your ISP before you make the changeover.
Third, make sure your new V.90 modem has enough memory
to let you flash it up to all four standards you need:
V.34, K56flex, x2, and V.90. PC Card modems have
particular problems with this. Fourth, no matter how
good your modem is, if your line connection sucks, your
Internet connection sucks. This particularly applies to
hotel room connections for road warriors -- most hotels
run their 'Net connections through their PBX board,
guaranteeing poor quality of connection. You can use
this phone number to test your line connection:
847-262-6000. This number is provided as part of 3Com's
bulletin board. Use HyperTerminal to dial in, then enter
line as your first name and test as your
last name.
The BBS will, most of the time,
accurately identify the line you're on as 56k-compatible
or not. 3Com also provides a free phone line test
service at www.3com.com/56k/need4_56k/linetest.html.
Update: the new "V.92" standard is upon us; it's a
modest improvement on the V.90 standard, addressing the
Call Waiting issue as well as trying to eke more speed
out of the transmission (up to 44k uploads under ideal
situations). Find out more at www.itu.int/. Of
course, the whole fascination with analog modems is
about to disappear, now that digital connection
technology like DSL and cable are becoming more and more
available.