When is it
worth upgrading your old warhorse, and
when should you trade it in for a spiffy
new thoroughbred? Here are some tips for
deciding when it's worth upgrading and
when it isn't.
Your Use of Your PC. What
applications do you use on your PC? Do
you run resource-gobbling CAD apps,
state-of-the-art games, or advanced
graphics programs such as Adobe
Photoshop? If you're running such
programs on older PCs, you're wasting
too much time staring at an hourglass
cursor. Upgrade, or buy a new machine.
Spend most of your time working the keys
on a word processor or casual
Netsurfing? You don't need a
cutting-edge machine; your older machine
will probably do fine for you, perhaps
with an upgrade or two. Usually software
manufacturers provide "Required" and
"Recommended" hardware specifications
for their products; you can bet that
most "Required"" specs do little more
than get the program up and limping.
Your machine should meet or exceed the
"Recommended" specs for that program to
really giddyup. But use some common
sense, too. If your machine does what
you want it to do, then why upgrade?
Computer geeks and computing magazines
keep yelling, "More! More! More!" and
"Faster! Faster! Faster!" at us, but if
you don't need to do more or to go
faster, save your money and do something
else with it.
Memory. We've talked about memory
before, but it's worth repeating: a
memory upgrade provides the most bang
for the buck. We're talking as little as
$1-$4 per MB here. (Remember, your PC
loads running programs in RAM; if it
runs out, it's forced to "swap" back and
forth between loading and reloading
different portions of the program, and
that's a timewaster.) An old 486 needs
at least 16MB of RAM, and a jump to 32MB
will really get Windows up and running.
Lots of us are still running plain
vanilla Pentiums (Pentium Classics, some
shills are calling them) with 16MB under
the hood; zapping them to 32MB, 48MB, or
64MB definitely puts a tiger in their
tanks. Machines with Pentium IIs and/or
Pentium MMXs often come equipped with
32MB of RAM -- think about upping these
to 64MB or even 128MB. Added memory
speeds applications and makes it much,
much easier on your machine to run
multiple apps, particularly memory hogs
like PowerPoint, Office 97, or Lotus
Notes. Here's the tricky part: all
memory isn't alike. Old 486s and
Pentiums usually run a flavor of RAM
called EDO. Most P-IIs run SDRAM-66, and
newer, faster Pentium III/IV and AMD
Athlon systems prefer the hi-test
version called SDRAM-100. If you aren't
sure (and why would you be?), ask the
guru. Besides, even though this is
considered an "easy" upgrade, you're
probably smart to get someone to install
the new memory modules for you anyway,
so run it by him or her before you buy.
Just remember that some systems need
"parity" memory while others prefer
"non-parity," and that SIMM and DIMM
flavors of memory don't co-exist well,
even if your computer has sockets for
both (some P-MMX models have EDO DRAM
memory but include open DIMM sockets for
later upgrading).
Need to know exactly what kind of RAM
your system needs? Visit
www.kingston.com/ and click on "Find
the Memory You Need." You can search by
manufacturer, part number, or generic
memory. Kingston provides memory for
desktops, notebooks, servers,
workstations, routers, and printers as
well as flash memory.
CPU Upgrades. With sleek new
speed demon PCs available for way less
than $1000, upgrading your CPU and/or
your motherboard is much less of a
cost-effective upgrade than it used to
be. A few guidelines: If you own a
Pentium 66 or older PC, don't bother
with a chip upgrade, buy a new 'puter.
One magazine says if you own anything
slower than a P-200, buy a new one, but
I don't know about that. If you own a
P-75, P-90, P-100, and your BIOS can be
upgraded either by software or by
purchase of a new BIOS chip, AND your PC
uses a Socket 5 CPU module, you
might consider buying a packaged CPU
upgrade kit such as Evergreen's Mx-Pro
233 (www.evertech.com/) that
includes upgrade goodies such as a
cooling fan, a heat sink, software for
dealing with BIOS upgrades, and (most
importantly) a voltage converter.
(Systems with one of these chips but
without a Socket 5 CPU module can also
use Intel's 200-MHz Pentium Overdrive
Processor with MMX Technology Kit from
www.intel.com/). If you own a Pentium
Pro, consider Intel's Pentium II
Overdrive Processor with MMX Technology
Kit. Unfortunately, this upgrade costs
$550 -- probably not worth it. (Still,
if I were giving the advice, I'd say buy
a new machine. Why spend money to
upgrade to a slightly less obsolete
system?) If you have a Pentium faster
than 100MHz, or a Pentium II, you
can find an upgrade for relatively
cheap, and double your clock speed in
the process. (One machine I read about,
an old PII 350-MHz dinosaur, showed a
57% improvement in performance after the
owner installed an Evergreen 1.1 GHz
Performa III upgrade kit, for $170 and a
weekend's labor.) Don't plan on plugging
a P-II, III, or IV chip into your old
Pentium PC -- the chip sizes aren't the
same (clever devils at Intel, huh?), and
don't buy an ATX motherboard unless
you're already planning to buy a new
case to accompany it. (PowerLeap at
www.powerleap.com/ is another good
source of CPU upgrade kits.) Good news
on the CPU upgrade front: Evergreen is
marketing CPU upgrades on a PCI card,
which means that any computer that can
accept PCI cards (including some 486
systems) will be upgradable to P-II
performance levels. It should cost you
around $350 to $500 to upgrade your
critter to a Celeron II CPU with 64MB of
RAM. But if you really want to hot
things up, you need a motherboard
transplant, and that ain't even cheap;
with sub-$500 PCs out there that are
perfectly acceptable machines, why
bother? And by the way, do I need to
warn you to leave CPU installations to
those who are certified to do it?
Want to upgrade to an XP-compatible
system from a PII or old Celeron?
Evergreen sells a 1 GHz Celeron-based
upgrade kit that works nicely. Of
course, with the kit costing $260 plus
the time and labor of installing it, and
with new PCs selling for as low as $500,
you might not want to think about this.
If you don't want to transfer a lot of
files and programs from your old PC,
though, it's a choice worth considering.
If you're thinking of this type of PC
upgrade, take some precautions before
getting out the screwdrivers and the
bourbon. First, image your drive. CD-RW
disks are the easiest and cheapest way
to do this little chore. If you don't
see the need, then at least copy crucial
data files onto disk before moving
ahead. Next, XP users should call
1-888-571-2048 with their Product Key
number to avoid XP's balky Product
Activation hassle. All users should back
up their BIOS settings. Double-check
your expansion boards and cables to see
that everything is seated and connected
properly. And lastly, don't wear
polyester when you do this (or anything
involving playing with the hardware).
Polyester conducts static electricity,
and static electricity can fry your
system in a microsecond. This means you,
Leisure Suit Larry.
Hard Drives. A good choice for a
relatively cheap upgrade, and not a bad
way to test whether or not you can
actually perform surgery on your PC. If
you're running a 486 or old Pentium
(slower than, say, 90 MHz), then don't
bother -- instead, tuck your money away
for a new machine and save hard drive
space by archiving files or deleting
apps. If you're running an older
machine, think about an UltraDMA drive
with an UltraDMA controller, and be
prepared to upgrade your BIOS. Running a
PC less than a year old? Shoot for a 6GB
EIDE drive. (A smaller drive is
pointless, unless you're really, really
pinching pennies; $50 extra can buy you
2 or 3 more gigs of hard drive space --
not a bad bargain.) If you really want
to get into storage, you can go all the
way to a 17GB hard drive or higher. It
won't be cheap ($250+), but you'll have
hellacious drive space. If you run a PC
that acts as a network server, or runs
heavy data- or graphics-intensive apps,
you might prefer a SCSI hard drive. A
SCSI drive is more expensive but
operates such apps much better than the
industry-standard EIDE drives. Hard
drives aren't that difficult to install,
but definitely not an installation for
the novice. If you've been doing little
hardware tweaks such as installing more
RAM without running into difficulty,
then you might be up to the challenge of
installing a new hard drive. Otherwise,
let the wonks do it. Tip: since newer
hard disks are faster than the dinosaur
on your machine, install the new one as
your main C: drive and transfer
everything over. Use the older hard disk
for supplemental storage or data backup.
High-Capacity Floppy Disk Storage.
Adding secondary or new, larger hard
drives is one option. Another is to
install an Iomega Zip, Jazz, or Clik!
drive, a Castlewood Orb drive. or a
Superdisk LS-120. You'll enhance your
storage capabilities a good bit, and
you'll do it on the cheap (the basic Zip
or Superdisk drives start around $80,
and an Orb 2.2GB cartridge can be had
for $30).
New CD or DVD Drives. Don't even
consider upgrading your 4X CD-ROM to a
speedy new 32X or 40X drive, unless you
routinely access programs from your CD
drive. Why? Almost all software titles
are written for 2X or 4X drives, so your
faster drive won't get much chance to
flex its muscles. The only reasons to
install a fast new CD-ROM drive are
either because your old one is dead and
you don't want a DVD or CD-RW drive, or
you run programs from CDs frequently, in
which case you'll probably want to wring
every drop of speed you can from your CD
drive. DVD-ROM drives are the wave of
the future; if you're of a mind to
upgrade, think about replacing your CD
drive with a DVD drive instead. They
come in two flavors, DVD-ROM, which
plays both CDs and DVDs, and DVD-RAM,
which only plays DVD-RAM cartridges and
are primarily used for heavy-duty
storage. CD-RW drives are most useful
for those who do a lot of work with
music, graphics, or video files on their
PCs. (Forget the old fogey CD-R drives.
The CD-RW drives have superseded them,
and cost no more.) (Note: Budget
watchers, the onset of DVD drives has
driven the price of standard IDE CD
drives way, way down.) Of course, if
you're running a machine slower than a
P-II 350, a DVD is out of the question.
Even a CD-RW may balk on an older
machine. And unless you really, really
know what you're doing, don't even think
of installing a DVD-ROM drive. CD-RW and
DVD-RAM installations are no picnic,
either.
Graphics/Video Cards. A good
idea, right? Slap in a snazzy new video
card and watch those Klingon battle
cruisers snap to. Well, maybe not. Those
of us who do primarily word processing
or other work that doesn't depend on
heavy graphics reproduction probably
won't benefit much from a new video
card, unless you're into games. Gamers
love graphics, the faster and more
realistic the better. In that case,
either upgrade or save for a new
machine. If you run graphics-heavy apps
such as digital photo reproducers, you
should have at least 2MB of video memory
-- 4MB would be better. (Warning: the
new office apps such as Office 2000 are
a lot more graphics-intensive than their
predecessors, so a good graphics card is
a must for these programs.) An 8MB video
card is only useful for CAD or graphics
pros who use 21-inch or larger monitors.
It is possible (and labor-intensive) to
just upgrade the video RAM on your
current card, but it's a lot easier to
just stick a new video card in there.
Remember, all the video memory in the
world won't make Quake or
AutoCAD look good on a 15-inch
monitor, and if you don't have a good
grounding in working in a PC's innards,
you probably want to have a pro do this
install for you. The good news? A
top-flight video card compatible with
all but the very old machines can be had
for under $100.
Find out what kind of graphics card you
have by right-clicking My Computer,
selecting Properties, clicking the
Device Manager tab, and double-clicking
Display Adapters. The card and vendor
will be listed. To check the driver,
double-click on the card name and click
the Driver tab. In Win 98, open the
Components section of the System
Information utility
(Start/Programs/Accessories/System
Tools/System Information).
Sound Cards. Many older systems
don't even have stand-alone sound cards,
since their motherboards have integrated
sound chips. 3D sound, particularly
Microsoft's DirectSound3D, changed that.
Now a sound card is essential if you
want good 3D surround sound. Forget
about ISA cards, PCI is the wave of the
future, and much, much easier to set up
than ISA-based cards. Make sure your
PC's chassis has enough room for the new
sound cards. And choose a card that
offloads processor-intensive tasks to a
sound-processing chip, otherwise you'll
experience significant system slowdowns.
Modems. Agh. If you're running a
14.4kbps or slower modem, read no
further: upgrade that sucker right now.
Now. Go. If you're running a 28.8 or
33.6 modem, you definitely want to think
about going to a V.92 modem (the new
56kbps modems combining the old,
competing x2 and K56flex technologies).
If you already own an x2 or K56 modem,
you might be able to get a free upgrade
from your vendor (no promises about ease
of upgrade, though), but as the price of
V.92 modems continues to drop, look for
these upgrade offers to fade away.
However, if your ISP doesn't yet support
V.92, wait until they've switched over
before you switch, even if it means
plodding along under the older standard
for a while longer (visit
modemsite.com/56k/v92isp.asp to find
a compatible ISP in your area). External
modems are no harder to swap out than
swapping a printer, but changing an
internal modem is tricky. Thinking about
going to cable, ISDN, ADSL, or other
cutting-edge technologies? Check
here, and with your phone company
and your ISP before making the switch.
Ports. Hmm. You finally got that
digital scanner you've been hinting for,
you already have the printer, the
external modem, the digital camera, the
Zip drive...gee, you ran out of ports
two or three devices ago. Where to plug
all of those little bastards in? If
you're running a true Win98 machine, you
should think about going for a USB
upgrade kit (Entrega at
www.entrega.com sells a good one for
about $40). These use a PCI slot to
enable USB devices such as digital
cameras and scanners to run on slightly
older machines. Bandwidth-gobblers such
as external hard drives need SCSI
connections. Some of these devices ship
with their own SCSI connectors, but
manufacturers often ship cheaper SCSI
connectors which don't do the job. At
any rate, installing new SCSI connectors
isn't for the faint-hearted. On the
horizon: FireWire (1394) ports, already
a favorite of Mac users and coming soon
to a PC near you. On the whole, though,
installation of more ports is a tricky
thing that may be more cost and bother
than you want. If you've got an old
machine and lots of new devices, save
your $$ and buy a new PC that does the
gizmos justice.